Blog · Payroll tax

Too Much Social Security Tax Withheld From Two Jobs

Published November 8, 2026

Most employers must withhold Social Security tax from your wages. Some government employers do not. Railroad employers withhold two railroad taxes instead, called tier 1 and tier 2 RRTA tax. In each case, the amount withheld should not be more than the yearly maximum. Sometimes it is.

This post explains the two common ways this happens and what the IRS says to do. It does not calculate your amount. Your Forms W-2 show the withholding.

Case 1: one employer withheld too much

Suppose a single employer took out more Social Security tax than the rules allow. The IRS says you generally cannot claim that excess as a credit on your income tax return. Your employer should correct the amount for you.

If the employer does not fix the overcollection, you can file Form 843, which is the IRS form for claims and requests to abate tax. Attach copies of your Forms W-2 for the year. Keep copies for your own records.

Case 2: two or more employers

Each employer withholds Social Security tax on its own, up to the yearly wage limit. Your employers do not know what you earned from the others. If your total wages were above the wage base limit for the year, the total withheld can be more than the maximum for the year.

When that happens, you may be able to claim the excess as a credit on your income tax return. The IRS points to the section called "Excess Social Security and tier 1 RRTA tax withheld" in the Instructions for Form 1040 and Form 1040-SR. Read that section before you file.

If you had more than one railroad employer and too much tier 2 RRTA tax was withheld, you request the excess with Form 843. Attach copies of your Forms W-2 for the year.

Steps in order

A simple order helps. First, read the Social Security tax box on each Form W-2. Second, add the wages from all of your jobs and compare the total with the wage base limit for the year. Third, if one employer took too much, ask that employer to correct it before you take any other step. Fourth, if the employer does not correct it, use Form 843 for that employer's excess. Fifth, if you had more than one employer, use the Form 1040 instructions for the credit. Keep copies of every form you send and every form you receive.

Joint returns

If you file a joint return, you and your spouse figure any excess Social Security tax or tier 1 RRTA tax separately. Each spouse's Forms W-2 should be checked on their own.

Check your Forms W-2 first

Before you claim anything, check the Social Security tax box on each Form W-2. Add the amounts from all of your jobs. Compare the total to the wage base limit for the year. For help reading Form W-2, see Form W-2 Boxes: What They Mean and How to Check Your Pay Stubs.

Keep copies of your Forms W-2 with your tax records. For how long, read How Long Should I Keep My Tax Records?.

Tax on self-employment income follows different rules. If you had self-employment income, read Self-Employment Tax: The Basics of Schedule SE. If the employer did not withhold tax it should have, the form that reports uncollected tax is different. See Form 8919: Social Security and Medicare Tax When You Were Treated as a Contractor. If you already filed and find an error, read How Do I Fix a Mistake on a Return I Already Filed?.

This post is general information. It is not tax advice for your return.

Sources: Sources: IRS, Tax Topic 608, Excess Social Security and RRTA tax withheld (https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc608); the Form 1040 instructions are referenced by that topic but were not read in full This is general information, not advice about your specific return.

More guides on: Retirement and pensions

← Back to the blog · Leer en español

Get tax updates in your inbox

Occasional emails about deadlines, tax-law changes and File US Taxes news. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.